top of page
Search

Transcribe with Nathan Graybeal

Oct 28
7 min read

If you ever listened back to one of your solos and thought, "Wow, that didn't sound very melodic,” well, you're not alone. This is something every improviser goes through. We spend so much time practicing all the techniques—like scales and chords and patterns, but then when it's time to improvise, it's so easy to fall into the trap of playing idea after idea, but not really connecting them in a coherent way. But the good news is, being melodic isn't something that you're born with. It's something that you can practice. 


So today, we'll learn how to transcribe together and apply it through our solos. We'll analyze and fully break down the transcription, and so you can apply it to any tune. Then we’ll look at how to combine all these techniques over well-known jazz standards. 


And if you're interested in going deeper in these topics, make sure to check out our course Melodic Improvisation. In the course, we take the concepts from today even further with guided exercises, musical examples, and application over jazz standards. And if you want to see how Nathan plays through anything that we talk about today, make sure to check out our accompanying YouTube video “Transcribe with Nathan Graybeal.”


Let’s get playing!


Contents


The purpose of transcription

Let’s talk about why we transcribe. Everyone's going to have slightly different philosophies and opinions on this. Nathan’s is that there's a difference between improvisation and jazz improvisation. 


Improvisation has existed for 1000s and 1000s of years, but jazz improvisation is a very special language. It was born of people getting together, ultimately like a folk music, and people shared their ideas and discoveries with each other. 


And a lot of the language comes from the melodies of jazz standards, which were the pop tunes of their time. It would be like us playing Ariana Grande, Bruno Mars, or Taylor Swift, even. And there is a lot of ideas that we would probably never stumble upon ourselves through our own improvisation. But when we hear it and someone else is playing, it can really jump out to us, and we're like, "Oh, I really want to go that direction. Let me take some of that.”


And it's a very important skill to be able to know how to take music that you hear and like and to be able to know how to put it in your own playing. Now, the goal should not be to try to become a vocabulary machine where everything you play is some recitation of a transcription that you've done. The spirit of jazz is still truly improvisation, but ideally you want all your favorite players to influence your own sound that you're constantly developing. 


Let’s go over how to take those solos you love and some strategies that you can do to get those concepts into your own improvisation. 


Transcribing solos by ear

We're going to transcribe a chorus together of “This I Dig of You,” and particularly Hank Mobley's solo. We’ll look at Nathan’s process and we can go through the solo together. 


When we hear a line, we can take smaller fragments, but you should always try to sing it first. You don't need to be a good singer, but if you can sing the notes in tune, that's all you need. 


The next step is to put it to the horn. We’ll take as small of a fragment as you need. You may want to go one note at a time or two notes at a time. As your ear develops, you can do longer and longer phrases. 

So here's that first phrase. Make sure you have every interval there, and if it's too fast, you can slow the reference recording down. Some people are very against slowing down. Folks from the older generation are especially against it because they couldn't slow it down. They had to use vinyl, and so they learned it that way. 


But Nathan has met lots of amazing musicians that do slow it down all the time, and sometimes you don't need to slow things down, especially if it's a familiar sound or something that you transcribed before. But if you're having a hard time hearing it at full speed and it's causing a lot of frustration, try slowing it down. 


Once you can sing it, go ahead and try to find it on your horn. And then you're just going to go phrase by phrase. Then try to connect those two phrases.


This next phrase is a familiar sound. It's the bebop scale. And we can slow this down because these are some pretty rapid notes. But, it's the major seven chord. 


And anytime we learn a new fragment, we can start back from the beginning and try to connect it all. 


This next line is fast, so you may try and transcribe at normal speed to sort of challenge your ear. But as soon as you feel like you’re struggling, slow it back down. 


Now, once you've transcribed a solo, it may be helpful to write it out, especially if you’re a visual learner. Some teachers are very anti-writing. But there are plenty of amazing players that do write and have embraced that they're visual learners. When you learn a new language, you bring your pencil and paper to class. It just helps connect with the audio. 


Of course, there are some things that you can't grasp visually, so you always have to make sure your ears are open. Try writing it out yourself. Nathan doesn’t like to read other people's transcriptions because it's such a personal process. But we have provided the written transcription for you here. Feel free to use it, but also try writing out your own transcription. 


Analyzing your transcriptions

Let's go ahead and analyze the solo. 

In that first line, we have two beats of rest. Then we have a 3, 5, 7, 1 — just the chord tones of the first chord. Then we have a really cool bebop technique that a lot of the beboppers of the past have done. When we play that fourth note, we sort of voice-lead into the 7 of the next chord. It's a ii chord pedaled over the 5, and then we walk down those chord tones. 


From there, we play a common tone diminished chord to the root. A common tone diminished chord is when your diminished chord shares at least one chord tone with the chord that you're resolving to. In this case, we're going to the iii chord, but the iii chord is a rootless Imaj9 chord. A iii chord is always interchangeable with the tonic, so most people aren't even thinking ”I'm gonna play a concert Dm7 here because if you use D Dorian, it's gonna sound really bad.” 


We are retaining that concert Eb within that iii chord, so we're really just playing the iii chord of the major scale that we're in, which is Bbmaj. And when that's the case, your iii chord is always totally interchangeable with the one chord. So that's why this line works. 


So this common tone diminished chord is connected to the one chord. We have a Bbdim, and that's a technique that you can do. It's really a substitution you can add whenever you want to resolve to a one chord. 


So let's play a ii-V-I in this key. That's a really cool thing that you can do, and particularly that line. What he's doing is he's playing the tonic fully diminished chord, but he's playing 3, b5, and 7. The major seven naturally exists within the diminished scale. And that's why this sound works so well. It is a common tone diminished chord resolving to one. 


Applying new vocabulary

Let's talk about how we can take one of those phrases and apply it to our solos. 


Try using a phrase that really jumped out at you before you even understood what the line was, before you even transcribed it. Because if it jumped at you just by listening to it, then people who are like you will gravitate towards your solos when you're starting to play material like the one you're trying to absorb within your own improvisation, Your heart is the strongest marker of what pieces of vocabulary you should spend your time on. 


And what's sort of funny is something can really jump out at you, and then when you actually break it down, you're like, "Oh, this is actually really simple. It's just 3, 5, 3, 2, 1.” 


Whenever Nathan finds a phrase, the first thing he does is just try to get in 12 keys. Let's take a phrase and bring it through the cycle of fourths. 


Now once you have it in 12 keys, the next step is to apply it to a tune. We're going to take “Recordame” by Joe Henderson. 

So how can you apply a line like this to a tune? It is a major line, so we know that it's going to work based on the root of your major seven chords. It's also going to work based on the root of a dominant seventh chord because there's no sevenths present. 


Now let’s see if you can take this line and use it as a means for motif development. Try to improvise using this line, and then abandon it to create your own phrases, while still using this as a template to have a recurring motif that you are continually developing and evolving. 

Alright, that’s all for today, but if you want to dive even deeper on any of this, make sure to check out our Melodic Improvisation course. And of course if you want to hear Nathan play through anything we talked about today, make sure to watch our accompanying YouTube video, "Transcribe with Nathan Graybeal."


We’ll see you next time!

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page